| 1970 | 
Ada Louise Huxtable | 
New York Times, for distinguished criticism during 1969
 | 
| 1971 | 
Harold C. Schonberg | 
New York Times, for his music criticism during 1970
 | 
| 1972 | 
Frank Peters, Jr | 
St. Louis Post-Dispatch, for his music criticism during 1971
 | 
| 1973 | 
Ronald Powers | 
Chicago Sun-Times, for his critical writing about television during 1972
 | 
| 1974 | 
Emily Genauer | 
Newsday, for her critical writing about art and artists
 | 
| 1975 | 
Roger Ebert | 
Chicago Sun-Times, for his film criticism during 1974
 | 
| 1976 | 
Alan M. Kriegsman | 
Washington Post, for his critical writing about dance during 1975
 | 
| 1977 | 
William McPherson | 
Washington Post, for his contribution to "Book World."
 | 
| 1978 | 
Walter Kerr | 
New York Times, for articles on the theater in 1977 and throughout his long career
 | 
| 1979 | 
Paul Gapp | 
Chicago Tribune, architecture
 | 
| 1980 | 
William A. Henry III | 
Boston Globe, for critical writing about television
 | 
| 1981 | 
Jonathan Yardley | 
Washington Star, for his book reviews
 | 
| 1982 | 
Martin Bernheimer | 
Los Angeles Times, for classical music criticism
 | 
| 1983 | 
Manuela Hoelterhoff | 
Wall Street Journal, for her wide-ranging criticism on the arts and other subjects
 | 
| 1984 | 
Paul Goldberger | 
New York Times, for architectural criticism
 | 
| 1985 | 
Howard Rosenberg | 
Los Angeles Times, for his television criticism
 | 
| 1986 | 
Donal Henehan | 
New York Times, for his music criticism
 | 
| 1987 | 
Richard Eder | 
Los Angeles Times, for his book reviews
 | 
| 1988 | 
Tom Shales | 
Washington Post, for his television criticism
 | 
| 1989 | 
Michael Skube | 
News and Observer (Raleigh, North Carolina), for his writing about books and other literary topics
 | 
| 1990 | 
Allan Temko | 
San Francisco Chronicle, for his architecture criticism
 | 
| 1991 | 
David Shaw | 
Los Angeles Times, for his critiques of the way in which the media, including his own paper, reported the McMartin Pre-School child molestation case
 | 
| 1992 | 
(no award)
 | 
  | 
| 1993 | 
Michael Dirda | 
Washington Post, for his book reviews
 | 
| 1994 | 
Lloyd Schwartz | 
Boston Phoenix, for his skillful and resonant classical music criticism
 | 
| 1995 | 
Margo Jefferson | 
New York Times, for her book reviews and other cultural criticism
 | 
| 1996 | 
Robert Campbell | 
Boston Globe, for his knowledgeable writing on architecture
 | 
| 1997 | 
Tim Page | 
Washington Post, for his lucid and illuminating music criticism
 | 
| 1998 | 
Michiko Kakutani | 
New York Times, for her passionate, intelligent writing on books and contemporary literature
 | 
| 1999 | 
Blair Kamin | 
Chicago Tribune, for his lucid coverage of city architecture, including an influential series supporting the development of Chicago's lakefront area
 | 
| 2000 | 
Henry Allen | 
Washington Post, for his fresh and authoritative writing on photography
 | 
| 2001 | 
Gail Caldwell | 
Boston Globe, for her insightful observations on contemporary life and literature
 | 
| 2002 | 
Justin Davidson | 
Newsday, for his crisp coverage of classical music that captures its essence
 | 
| 2003 | 
Stephen Hunter | 
Washington Post, for his authoritative film criticism that is both intellectually rewarding and a pleasure to read
 | 
| 2004 | 
Dan Neil | 
Los Angeles Times, for his one-of-a-kind reviews of automobiles, blending technical expertise with offbeat humor and astute cultural observations
 |